-
Usman2
hello
-
Usman2
Do yall have a discord or something, or is this the main way to chat?
-
nicoco
This is the main way to chat.
-
nicoco
Gram was created in reaction to ensloppification, wouldn't it be weird to use a microsoft-owned, privacy-terrible, hyper-centralised, human-hostile online service to host its community chat? I would find it odd to draw a line at "no AI" and yet not have any issues with using discord. I am an outlier though, I realised over time many people here are Apple product users, which is awkward to me, as I basically have the same issues with Apple than I have with OpenAI/Anthropic/… ✊😋🏴☠️
😀 1 -
krig
yeah I am an apple user… can’t justify throwing away the hardware I already own. But I won’t be buying anything new from them. The AI stuff is really the final straw…
-
nicoco
hehe I know, this was not meant as an attack
-
nicoco
Not throwing away hardware is a very valid reason to use stuff IMHO.
-
nicoco
Also, I *have* to be tolerant to behaviour I consider unethical because otherwise I would have to live alone in the forest. And obviously I have my paradoxes too :)
-
krig
no offense taken, it’s just really frustrating and when it comes to phones there’s basically no option, I refuse to jump from Apple to Google but those are the only options
-
luca
Discord isn't Microsoft owned though?
-
nicoco
luca: oh right, it was not bought after all, my bad
-
nicoco
It is proprietary, centralised, and even actively hostile to 3rd party clients though, so it makes me oh so very sad to see so many FLOSS project using it as their main "community place".
-
krig
Yeah I am also not a fan of discord and that kind of private walled garden, you just know it’ll get more and more enshittified
-
nicoco
krig, FWIW, lineageos without google service is very usable on a lot of android phones. My phone is a samsung S7 that my partner found too "slow" a few years back. It is just fine for me. It is too slow to doomscroll instagram or facebook via their website, which is a feature anyway.
-
nicoco
One of the thing I hate the most about discord is their "servers" which make it sound like it's decentralised somehow.
-
nicoco
This is so confusing that it's actually called a "guild" in their APIs and internals. 🤡
-
krig
I have also considered a Jolla, but I have some apps I need for work which makes it difficult. And in Sweden we have this bankid thing which you just can’t get by without.. which apparently needs google play services
-
nicoco
maybe lineageos+microg is viable for this bankid thing? https://github.com/microg/
-
krig
oh interesting, yeah maybe
-
Usman2
Have u considered using fluxer? it is open source, selfhosted and much better already than discord even before being 1.0. Features still being added
-
Usman2
I have actually moved some of my planned FOSS projects over to fluxer, from discord being the 'community hub'
-
Usman2
https://fluxer.app/
-
krig
I have thought about fluxer yeah, haven’t tried it though
-
krig
Have to say I am happy with this XMPP chat. I don’t want to have to deal with too much moderation
-
krig
and it’s very nice that @nicoco is taking care of running it 😄
❤ 1 -
nicoco
the very nice thing about hosting a XMPP server is that it's basically no maintainance, and that it requires the computing power of a 20 years old toaster for a few thousand users :)
-
krig
still some work to do before gram is usable on a toaster sadly
-
nicoco
fluxer has a nice mission statement, I wish they'd built on top of XMPP but they fell into the usual "chat is easy, let's reinvent from scratch" and "http is the only protocol that exists now, everything must use HTTP"
-
nicoco
but I'll write a gateway if we move to fluxer ;)
-
nicoco
> still some work to do before gram is usable on a toaster sadly well, yeah, especially building on a toaster is hard xD ↺
-
nicoco
I wish I understood more gl/vulkan thing to port zed's opengl backend so gram runs on my oldish laptops :(
-
krig
need a beefy toaster yeah
-
nicoco
I settled on using more basic editors or… zed on these older laptops
-
krig
yeah I want to fix that too, I just don’t have time
-
nicoco
gram was my gateway drug into zed I guess :)
-
krig
haha oh no
-
nicoco
> yeah I want to fix that too, I just don’t have time oh sweet, I thought it would be too much maintainance overhead to have both backends ↺
-
krig
I wonder what will happen with zed, I have no idea if the delta thing is working out for them or what they will do either way
-
krig
they have it working on GL in zed I think so it should be possible to backport whatever they did there
-
nicoco
mmm https://zed.dev/blog/introducing-delta > multiplayer environment for coding with agents and reviewing what they build OK. multiplayer is a fun word for a code editor xD
-
krig
worst case I could write a pure GL backend without using wgpu.. it’s not impossible. But takes time
-
nicoco
gl/vulkan seems so overkill for displaying text, but I don't know much about it TBH
-
krig
it doesn’t seem like they are even making a code editor anymore
-
krig
just an interface to chat with bots
-
nicoco
yes, because we all love speaking to and being spoken to by machines, don't we?
-
krig
vulkan is a messy API but it’s a very direct way to talk to the GPU, lower level than opengl. But yeah kind of ridiculous to require a GPU to edit text
-
krig
I honestly don’t understand a word of what zed are doing lately 😄 but that’s fine, gram is OK on its own now I think. Biggest challenge is keeping up with changes in dependencies like if tree-sitter makes some breaking change
-
nicoco
Yes the number of external crates is a bit scary, but you have done great so far. I have happily not got back to PyCharm since I started using gram. Good work!
-
Usman2
sorry i missed the bit with fluxer, and i cant scroll up in this potatoe chatroom. What was the verdict on fluxer?
-
nicoco
Usman2: you can make an account and use a better client if you want a better UX for the chat. gajim is OK
-
ycna07
GPUI-CE is enforcing a strict AI policy while also cleaning up slop code. Is it possible to migrate our GPUI to CE to reduce the workload?
-
nicoco
Usman: > krig: I have thought about fluxer yeah, haven’t tried it though > krig: Have to say I am happy with this XMPP chat. I don’t want to have to deal with too much moderation
-
nicoco
https://chat.slidge.im:5281/file_share/01a162fe-f25a-74af-aed9-ee6af20270e2/7a7c5112-12d1-499f-8cf9-af2d385c249e.png
-
nicoco
"chat is easy, let's make a new protocol!"
-
Usman2
@nicoco Thanks. What client do u use for this? The web version is really basic.
-
Usman2
Funny thing, i just got acquinted with rust GUI libraries today, and just right now read about GPUI-CE. A community, more general purpose edition of zed's GPUI library. If people contribute and develop it GPUI-CE could become a major rust GUI library for everything - just as their goals themselves state
-
krig
We’ve already drifted very far from GPUI-CE, I don’t want to throw away the work we’ve done at this point. I did talk to them early on to see if it was a possibility but our goals were not aligned back then at least, no idea how things may have changed since
-
krig
but yeah I have basically rewritten the whole platform stack on Mac OS, it’s very different from zed or gpui-ce
-
Usman2
is it something different than GPUI-CE? like a new library? Or are you talking about macOS specific GUI
-
Usman2
why choose xmpp over others then @nicoco :p Im using this for the first time lmao
-
artsi0m
> why choose xmpp over others then @nicoco :p > Im using this for the first time lmao It's federated and has opensource clients and servers ↺
👈 1 -
nicoco
Usman: the reason why is that there was no chat or forum for gram, and I offered to host one. as to "why xmpp in general", it's an open protocol with an open governance and it's very easy to self-host
❤ 1 -
artsi0m
> why choose xmpp over others then @nicoco :p > Im using this for the first time lmao https://gultsch.de/posts/25-years-of-digital-independence/ ↺
-
Usman2
why not use matrix over xmpp then It seems somewhat more modern and with addressed limitations of xmpp
-
nicoco
I know that clients are not perfect, but chat/instant messaging has been reinvented so many times, and I believe this is part of why silos such as WhatsApp, Telegram or Discord thrive.
-
nicoco
Instead of keeping on reinventing the wheel, let's build on standards ratified by IETF.
-
artsi0m
> why not use matrix over xmpp then > It seems somewhat more modern and with addressed limitations of xmpp Search for matrix there: https://gultsch.de/posts/25-years-of-digital-independence/#standards ↺
-
nicoco
Matrix is fine but solved none of the limitations of XMPP. The so-called limitations of XMPP are largely FUD they spread to get people (and investors) behind them.
❤ 1 -
nicoco
Hosting a matrix server requires order of magnitude more resources than hosting an XMPP server.
-
nicoco
And matrix governance is "pay more, have more votes" so I wouldn't really call it open or democratic
-
Usman2
Im basically totally new to this, so matrix is vendor locked? And not truly decentralized? Is that happening on the proocol level or the client and application level as well
-
Usman2
Damn, this thing feels like a rabbit hole - the whole messaging protocol and the cascade limitless of them out there
-
nicoco
(krig please moderate me if this is too off-topic, I'm happy to be the XMPP salesperson but maybe this is a bit noisy for most occupants here…)
❤ 1 -
artsi0m
> (krig please moderate me if this is too off-topic, I'm happy to be the XMPP salesperson but maybe this is a bit noisy for most occupants here…) Same ↺
-
Usman2
anyways, thanks. Im downloading gajim client for xmpp. That was what was recommended . If u have a better one do tell
-
nicoco
matrix is decentralized in theory, in practice the flagship server has most users by far, because self-hosting is a PITA. there is one main reference server implementation which is "open core", you need to pay for the version "that scales bettter". other server implementations exist but are not totally compliant. just like in XMPP, clients have implemented custom extensions that don't interoperate well with others, which is inevitable in an open ecosystem (but somehow matrix managed to convince people that this would not happen to them — it did)
-
nicoco
I like gajim, but I am biased since I contributed a few small things.
❤ 1 -
artsi0m
> Im basically totally new to this, so matrix is vendor locked? And not truly decentralized? Is that happening on the proocol level or the client and application level as well > It's more nuanced than answering abosolutely yes to both of the questions. ↺
-
artsi0m
Also my comrade from one of the unrecognized states said that he tried to selfhost matrix and xmpp, but peering with other servers was easier to him on xmpp. Couldn't be an argument because of appeal to own experience, but still...
-
Usman2
ahh got it. It seems xmpp is actually better given all this. Matrix is one of those 'hey look im open and for everyone' but reality is a bit different
-
nicoco
> Damn, this thing feels like a rabbit hole - the whole messaging protocol and the cascade limitless of them out there Well you can add deltachat to XMPP and matrix for open federated chat protocol. again, it's fine, but reinventing the wheel once again is not the best approach to fighting the silos IMHO. I don't think they do public groups like this one though. Funnily enough, there isn't even an official deltachat chatroom anywhere TTBOMK 😆
-
Usman2
anyways for gajim, im signing up. What provider is best from the list of them on the sign up
-
nicoco
Deltachat governance seem less problematic than Matrix but… why didn't they build on top of XMPP is a complete mystery to me. They chose IMAP and SMTP which are… awkward choices IMHO.
-
nicoco
any server is fine, I think the list comes from https://providers.xmpp.net/
❤ 1 -
artsi0m
> anyways, thanks. Im downloading gajim client for xmpp. That was what was recommended . If u have a better one do tell > I use gajim too. Usually that do e2e out of the box are also the most ergonomic ones https://omemo.top/ ↺
-
nicoco
OMEMO is not suited for public rooms such as this one though (arguably E2EE does not make much sense for public rooms in general)
-
artsi0m
> OMEMO is not suited for public rooms such as this one though (arguably E2EE does not make much sense for public rooms in general) Sure. I just said that client that handles omemo usually also would be easy to use ↺
👍 1 -
Usman2
basically , i meant to say, that as you said : Matrix doesnt really provide any benefits over xmpp, the new v2 is still in infancy and is actually not truly decentralized and open. So xmpp is clearly better if it is improving, actually open, and has everything.
-
nicoco
"Everything" is a lot! ;-) Clients could be improved, for sure. Using gram to contribute to them, maybe? :P
❤ 1 -
Usman2
can u give link for this chat , so i can use it in gajim
-
artsi0m
> can u give link for this chat , so i can use it in gajim > xmpp:gram@rooms.slidge.im?join ``` xmpp:gram@rooms.slidge.im?join ``` ↺
-
Usman2
it says this address is not reachable
-
Usman2
cant connect using this link
-
artsi0m
> it says this address is not reachable > Provider? You could try to contact your xmpp provider operator regarding the issues with connecting to other servers ↺
-
Usman2
u sure this works on gajim?
-
Usman2
the linnk you gave?
-
artsi0m
> u sure this works on gajim? > [+] (plus sign) -> Start/Join chat, paste the link her✎ ↺ -
artsi0m
> u sure this works on gajim? > [+] (plus sign) -> Start/Join chat, paste the link here ✏ ↺
-
Usman2
i did that, after a few seconds, it says address unreachable
-
Usman2
it just randomly worked now. Ig there is a backend new account timer that needs to be crossed to join
-
usman3255
hello all
-
GnarlyOtaku
Least though you can connect xmpp and matrix together via bridges
🛷 1 -
usman3255
this is me from gajim
🍾 2 -
Usman2
idk whats the issue, except for that 1 time when connection succeeded, i keep getting unreachable error. Mabye it has something to do with the server i signed up with. It was the top of the list . idk. ill investigate
-
ycna07
> We’ve already drifted very far from GPUI-CE, I don’t want to throw away the work we’ve done at this point. I did talk to them early on to see if it was a possibility but our goals were not aligned back then at least, no idea how things may have changed since May I ask what the disagreement was at that time? ↺
-
krig
They intended to keep pace with upstream and pull in all the patches, whereas I don’t want to, I disagree with the direction of upstream and the amount of AI generated code. So I try to be more selective